Take the 2-minute tour ×
Bicycles Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for people who build and repair bicycles, people who train cycling, or commute on bicycles. It's 100% free, no registration required.

My wife's bicycle has Shimano Revoshift shifters, and while the right (rear) one works fine, the left (front, Friction) has been problematic for a while. Originally, when we bought the bicycle, the left shifter made a clicking sound when it was turned. After a while, it stopped clicking, and since last summer, it has required tons of force to shift from the middle gear to the biggest gear.

I've tried to adjust the front derailleur (orientation, height) and the low and high limits, as well as the cable tightness, but nothing seems to remedy the force. This morning, I took the shifter apart, suspecting that something would be broken inside it, but everything seemed OK. I put it back together, but it still doesn't click and I have to use both hands to turn the lever to get it to the biggest gear.

I suspect that there's still something wrong going on in the shifter, though. If I gently pull the cable underneath the body, the shifter rotates. It shouldn't do that, should it?

The exact model is Shimano SL-RS35. Thanks for any help in advance!

share|improve this question
    
Did you try lubricating the cable? –  Daniel R Hicks May 31 at 15:59
add comment

1 Answer 1

Some of the revoshifts are actually friction and just don't click period, while others are pseudo-friction (they click in small increments so you can trim your shifts) - I suspect you have the latter. They are also the bargain bin parts (less than 20 dollars for a set), and thus are built with low quality and things often go wrong. Pretty much all you can do is check that the cable tension is OK, the cable isn't caught on anything and the derailleur is set up properly (If the shifter is gunked up, sometimes flushing it with WD40 helps, but thats just a temporary fix).

As suggested in this question, I recommend throwing out the RevoShift shifters if they start to cause problems and then replacing them with some other cheap shifters (maybe switch the left on a cheap thumb friction shifter, or a Shimano trigger shifter with the same number of speeds, or a SRAM Attack front shifter if you want to stick with twist).

share|improve this answer
    
Dunno about RevoShift in particular, but I know that when I was rehabbing bikes for charity the twist shifters were the single component most likely to need replacement. –  Daniel R Hicks May 1 at 14:44
    
RevoShift now comes on the more expensive BSO's these days - its mostly below Tourney, though some Revoshifts are Tourney (with the ranking Tourney < Altus < Acera < Alivio < Deore < other stuff I can't afford). –  Batman May 1 at 15:03
    
@Batman I checked the local bicycle parts shop, and the exact same shifter is 4.95 there - it's the cheapest one they have. There's also SRAM MRX Comp shifter for 8.95, should I go with that? –  manabreak May 7 at 12:42
    
Of the two options, the MRX Comp 3.0 (presumably what it is) is the better option, but I'd probably shell out a bit extra and buy a Shimano Acera front trigger shifter (which will likely cost twice as much). But if you have to go gripshift, the MRX comp is probably the better choice. Also, note that how good shifting occurs is dependent on how well the cables are routed and installed to some extent. –  Batman May 7 at 18:17
add comment

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.