Skip to main content

When replacing the rear brake pads I noticed that 4 spokes were broken and the wheel wobbles. I phoned a local bike shop and was told that they recommend replacing the wheel if more than 3 spokes are broken.

I assume that this is a safety precaution but wonder if the recommendation is in line with common practice. I certainly have no desire to get thrown off the bike in traffic, but it also seems a waste to (probably) discard an entire wheel because it might be damaged and might fail at some point.

This is a 27" road bike, inexpensive, which I ride for transportation in the city (Tokyo).

The rear rim is a bit scored from waiting too long to replace the brake pad, which is another factor to consider.

To clarify slightly, it probably would be cheaper to replace the wheel as suggested below. My objection is more of an ethical one -- tossing something useful into a hole in the ground seems irresponsible. Difficult to avoid though, the way things work right now.

When replacing the rear brake pads I noticed that 4 spokes were broken and the wheel wobbles. I phoned a local bike shop and was told that they recommend replacing the wheel if more than 3 spokes are broken.

I assume that this is a safety precaution but wonder if the recommendation is in line with common practice. I certainly have no desire to get thrown off the bike in traffic, but it also seems a waste to (probably) discard an entire wheel because it might be damaged and might fail at some point.

This is a 27" road bike, inexpensive, which I ride for transportation in the city (Tokyo).

The rear rim is a bit scored from waiting too long to replace the brake pad, which is another factor to consider.

When replacing the rear brake pads I noticed that 4 spokes were broken and the wheel wobbles. I phoned a local bike shop and was told that they recommend replacing the wheel if more than 3 spokes are broken.

I assume that this is a safety precaution but wonder if the recommendation is in line with common practice. I certainly have no desire to get thrown off the bike in traffic, but it also seems a waste to (probably) discard an entire wheel because it might be damaged and might fail at some point.

This is a 27" road bike, inexpensive, which I ride for transportation in the city (Tokyo).

The rear rim is a bit scored from waiting too long to replace the brake pad, which is another factor to consider.

To clarify slightly, it probably would be cheaper to replace the wheel as suggested below. My objection is more of an ethical one -- tossing something useful into a hole in the ground seems irresponsible. Difficult to avoid though, the way things work right now.

Tweeted twitter.com/StackBicycles/status/651660256108539905
Source Link
Tyler
  • 111
  • 1
  • 1
  • 3

Replace rim because of 4 broken spokes?

When replacing the rear brake pads I noticed that 4 spokes were broken and the wheel wobbles. I phoned a local bike shop and was told that they recommend replacing the wheel if more than 3 spokes are broken.

I assume that this is a safety precaution but wonder if the recommendation is in line with common practice. I certainly have no desire to get thrown off the bike in traffic, but it also seems a waste to (probably) discard an entire wheel because it might be damaged and might fail at some point.

This is a 27" road bike, inexpensive, which I ride for transportation in the city (Tokyo).

The rear rim is a bit scored from waiting too long to replace the brake pad, which is another factor to consider.