19

I was watching the BMX racing on the 2012 Olympics and the gearing seems incredibly low. About half way down the start ramp they are already going too fast to keep pedalling and they barely seem to be able to pedal effectively any other time through the race.

Why don't they adjust the gearing to be higher so they can get more power down through the course?

  • 1
    Did you mean "so low"? Your description suggests that the gearing is actually too low. Yet for some reason you keep saying "too high", until in the last sentence you suddenly suggest that it should be adjusted even higher. (???) – AnT Aug 10 '12 at 6:25
  • The UCI rules say "Multiple speed gear systems are permitted", so I'm surprised nobody seems to be using one - uci.ch/Modules/BUILTIN/… – Tom77 Aug 10 '12 at 9:06
  • I loved the BMX in the olympics. As it goes, looks like soon they will abolish saddles, too, since they seem to only touch them before landing on their faces after a bad reception :oP (ouch!) – heltonbiker Aug 10 '12 at 17:50
  • 1
    The problems with multi-gear far out weigh the advantage, not enough straight and too much torque. As for the seats, it is a safety issue so you don't get skewered in a crash on the seat post. Most seats are nothing more than a seatpost cap. – BillyNair Aug 10 '12 at 18:37
20

The tracks do not have many long stretches and so cornering and getting ahead of the pack is a lot more important than going fast in the flats. The gearing on a race BMX is higher than on one you will buy out of the store. Most BMX will come with 44:16 gear ratio where racers will use 46-48:16, and I have seen higher. (There are different rear sizes but the standard is 16 when talking about Gear Ratios, even if you ride 9t or 14t rear you almost always know the conversion to 16t.)

Most racers will start with 44/45:16 then move up when they build their leg muscles to handle the higher ratios, but even then you really need that hole-shot a lot more than you need the higher end speed.

If the tracks had longer straights like a mountain bike course you might see more bikes with multiple gears and even higher gearing. As it stands, the berms are where you make your moves and getting in and out of the berms require more power than raw speed. I raced 44:16 against guys with 46:16 and never placed lower than 3rd. You want more power than over all speed on a race track.

On street or in park you want even lower gearing, especially when you are trying to get that last pop before jumping up onto a rail.

  • Street/Park BMX gearing is usually 25:9. Mainly because you only need to pedal when you have no speed, and also to reduce the sprocket size so that it doesn't hit anything when doing tricks. – Fatalize Apr 24 '18 at 14:25
15

This is all my guessing based on BMX racing when I was younger, but getting ahead of the pack out of the starting gate is a rather big deal. Once you're behind or right next to someone else, you sometimes have to tap the brakes to avoid them, so there's a huge advantage to this sudden rush of acceleration.

This would be a clue as to at least an upper limit on gearing. You might have some advantage to higher gearing after the starting gate, but you wouldn't have the quick burst and you'd probably spend much of the race making up for it.

Much of the gear selection from at least stock BMX bikes has to do with age; I remember having a lot of difficulty with how high mine was geared because of my age. This would be why some youth-oriented BMX bikes have low gearing, although this doesn't apply at all to professional circuits.

  • 3
    It's exactly because of the acceleration. BMX courses put a premium on being the first to the turn so the start is critical. Recently, UCI rules governing BMX have been amended to allow gearing systems but BMX riders have eschewed them, in part because they put out a max instantaneous power in excess of 2000 watts and few bicycle gearing systems can take that much load without risking a missed shift. – R. Chung Aug 10 '12 at 11:12
1

There are two things no one has mentioned:

  1. This is a CONTACT SPORT, track have one PERFECT line, and is the one that first guy will use, and there are pretty low chances to have few other guys in the same race, with a better line or even the chance to select a better line. So elbows, cuts, hits and everything is allowed to get that PERFECT LINE.

    A few years ago, there were SINGLE SEEDS LAP to qualify TOP bikers (single biker lap) where some of them used to change the gearing.

  2. Basically, there are only short track sections where you can pedal and apply full power, and the whole stuff is around that issue. There were several attempts to use shifters, but nothing too effective (shifting and BMX aren't good friends)

    https://vimeo.com/31119376 (you can see BARRY NOBLES with 3 crashes because of XTR fails) enter image description here With that in mind, is all about RPM and legs speed. Having in mind that most powerful muscles acts for a very short time in a pedal stroke, then you need to see how to have more strokes instead a long one.

  • It's not clear to me how BMX being a contact sport implies that you want very low gearing. Could you expand on that? – David Richerby Oct 8 '17 at 12:05
  • sure David! The fact is that you need to win a 20 - 30 seconds race, with so many chances to pedal in 400 meters, where you will be obstructed / interrupted / hit / whatever... by other 7 guys. You have to fly away from all of those issues, the only way is to be one of those few at the top to turn the first corner. Believe me, you always want to have some way to shift your gearing in the race... but there isn't any SAFE and SMOOTH enough shifting system. RPM is the best solution, and we train that this way: youtube.com/watch?v=dWxAsN6xDKc – Andres Millan Oct 9 '17 at 22:15
0

It is because BMX racing is sprint racing. The riders stand and spin very quickly. There are a variety of crank lengths available which can help achieve higher cadences (RPM) based on your skill and leg length, and which in turn affect gear choice.

protected by Community Jan 30 '18 at 13:32

Thank you for your interest in this question. Because it has attracted low-quality or spam answers that had to be removed, posting an answer now requires 10 reputation on this site (the association bonus does not count).

Would you like to answer one of these unanswered questions instead?

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.