I don't have a whole lot of knowledge on this, but here goes. I have an old Murray Ultra mountain bike (prob. 15 yrs.+). It is a 15 speed bike, with a 5 speed freewheel. The whole Shimano system is the 515 which includes front and rear derailleurs.I really don't want to spend a lot of money on an upgrade, but an up grade of some sort is necessary because of simple wear and tear. All i'm asking is there a set,or equivalent where i can replace - at least the shifters to a more modern ones,and front derailleur without having to break the bank. At the very least the front derailleur and shifters.

2 Answers 2


Having restored a number of old cheap bikes, I can tell you that the biggest problem is almost never the derailleurs/shifters. Usually these bikes have not been ridden much and have spent most of their time in a garage exposed to the elements. The biggest problems are rusted parts, poor lubrication, and horrifically bad tuning. Frequently, on a bike like this you're likely to find that it was never properly put together.

Here's a quick checklist of things to go over that can be fixed economically:

If you have to replace the shifters or derailleurs, just try to find cheap replacements or used parts that are similar. You'll want to stick with 5-speed stuff, you aren't going to be upgrading to a 10 speed freewheel (they don't exist!).

  • 1
    You'll want to invest in a can of penetrating oil and a good deal of patience. Removing seized BB and headset locknuts has always resulted in much anguish and bloodshed for me.
    – WTHarper
    Dec 7, 2012 at 20:57

Sorry for the answer to an old post, but I've done this exact upgrade recently on my rear.

The bike is a 60cm frame, so it was worth saving. Originally it had a 5 speed freewheel and 3 front chainrings. Wheel rims were alloy. The rear spokes were made of spaghetti so I was replacing one or two a month.

I scored a rear wheel with a freehub and QR skewer in it, which just fit inside the frame with some minor encouragement.

I bought a 7 speed cassette for $45 NZ, and had to fit 3.5mm of spacers because it was actually an 8 speed freehub. Spacers cost $5.

The old 5 speed indexed shifter was useless so I fitted a Shimano one with a lever that clicks to go up, and a push button to drop a gear. Works well and cost about $25 NZ I also fitted a new gear inner wire because I could, cost $6 NZ.

I soldered the end of the gear cable rather than using a crimp-on cap.

I reused all the old outers, except I trimmed 10mm off where some of them were a bit sharp exiting the frame mounts. All outers were lubed with Wolf's oil (a cheap and lightweight chinese oil.)

Definitely worth doing, and I have not yet broken a spoke in 3 months of riding.

You should find your rear derailereuyueyrueyruer will work fine over 7 or 8 gears, but do take the change to clean and lube it.

I did not do anything with the front chainrings other than a clean and paint, and tweak up the limit screws. They're still on a friction shifter, which is fine for my needs.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.