I have a vintage (165mm-Crnk) Sugino 40/48 on here now, but am looking to add some gear range for up hill with med-sm load. I have a Tiagra short cage RD and a Sora double FD. I am friction shifting. I'm considering doing a chain ring like 26/36/48 with an 11-34 freewheel which would give me adequate range, I believe 20-117 ish.

Can I add a chainring to my set? Mine is 110mm 5 arm which sems like it should be replaceable with say a Shimano. I was also thinking I could just get a smaller maybe 36 tooth and call it a day with 2 rings.

My understanding so far is that my Tiagra rear derailleur has maximum of 28T. I've heard of people friction shifting using a double FD for triple front rings. Has anyone seen this?


Check out the IRD Defiant wide range double crankset http://store.somafab.com/irdwicorodoc.html) It has a 94bcd which allows it to run 46x30 rings. Combine that with a 12-27 cassette or freewheel and you'll have plenty of range.

Going to a triple presents a few problems:

  1. They don't shift as well as a double.
  2. You have a short cage rear derailleur so max rear cog is 27, maybe 30 teeth. Definitely won't handle 34 teeth.
  3. Triple cranks require triple compatible front derailleurs.
  4. A double is simpler and lighter.
  5. The Interloc will look a lot nicer on your 80s era bike.
  6. A triple will usually require a longer bottom bracket spindle than a double.
  • I'll check them out. I'm hoping to keep my cranks if possible as they are in fine condition..
    – Brendan
    Jul 3 '15 at 5:08
  • I'm leaning toward keeping a double ring set. I am finding a lot of good in simplicity and I've ridden with some dubious FD's.
    – Brendan
    Jul 4 '15 at 0:45

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.