I am wondering if I would be able to run the 105 5800 crankset with my 9 speed ultegra 5600 shifters/rd? I don't have the funds to do the whole groupset at once, and I believe upgrading to 11 speed would also mean that I need to get a new rear wheel.

Some more info / related questions: I have an 05 roubaix that has Ultegra 5600 Brakes/shifters and cassette/RD, and an fsa gossamer 52/39 crankset. the front derailleur has 3 positions although I just have 2 chainrings. the front derailleur shifts pretty terribly and the chain drops frequently when i shift down. do most front derailleurs have 3 positions even when there are only 2 chainrings? I set it up so that I can use the middle position to get away with some cross-chaining, but should I be doing this at all?

  • Correctly set-up Shimano front shifters have 4 positions, two very close together on each chainring for trimming purposes. When you fully shift to the bigger ring and just touch the lever afterwards the front derailleur moves a tiny bit to the inside. Same on the lower ring where a slight upshifting movement will bring the derailleur a tiny bit away from the inside position. This lets you adjust the postion when the chain rubs on the derailleur plates.
    – Carel
    Commented Aug 3, 2015 at 7:51

1 Answer 1


11 speed chain rings will be slightly narrower than 9 speed. So they will work, but it's not an ideal pairing. You should be able to keep your rear wheel and replace the 9 speed cassette with an 11. The dropout width hasn't changes, the gears have just got thinner.

Not sure what you mean by front derailleur having 3 positions. It swings through a fixed distance, it is the shifter that determines if there are 2 or 3 indexed points to stop at. A 3 speed shifter isn't going to work well with a 2 speed chain ring. But you try adjusting the lower limit screw to stop the chain dropping.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.