What are the warning signs that a crank (not the chainwheel etc, but the crank itself) is worn out and needs to be changed, or removed and cleaned? I have never changed mine in 5 years or so, because it seemed to fall into the category of 'it's working, don't mess with it'. It makes a bit of a grinding sound now and visibly has dirt in it, but still works fine. Do I wait till it breaks or what?

  • 1
    A crank -- axle, bearing, cups, and arms -- will last decades and 10s of thousands of miles if the bearings are not somehow damaged and the crank arms are not allowed to loosen. Your "grinding noise" is worrisome, though -- any bearing that makes noise is not long for this world. Oct 22, 2015 at 12:40
  • What kind of bottom bracket do you have? Oct 22, 2015 at 18:13

2 Answers 2


There are two cranks or crank arms on a bike - they connect the bottom bracket to the pedals. Some bikes have a "one piece crank" which combines the functions of the cranks and the bottom bracket axle.

There are four things that go wrong with crank arms

1 The threads for the pedal get stripped/damaged to the point the pedal gets undone easily

2 The mating hole for the bottom bracket fretts and is no longer a good fit. This often produces a creak on the power part of the stroke.

3 Cracked crank arm - if the mating hole wears, and is retightened enough times, the crank arm slides too far onto the bottom bracket. With time this can crack the weakest part of the circumference at the BB end of the crank. This can also happen at the pedal end, but that's unusual.

4 Bends and twists due to impact or accident - this is quite rare because crank arms tend to be very strong, much stronger than frames.

If your problem is the Bottom Bracket, then that's a whole different set of answers. Grinding could be bearings (check for play in the bottom bracket axle) or it could be a bad chainline, so the chain may be dragging on the front mech cage and your shifter wires need a tweak.


take out the chain and rotate the crankset as fast as you can, there shouldn't be any sound like creaking ir grinding. then check for any play. i generaly take out and clean mine every year. if you have shimano bottom bracket just outside clean and replace if something wrong with it. if it's sram gxp bottom bracket you should deep clean and grease it.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.