5

I need a new rear wheel for my mountain bike, and I'm wondering which of two options will be the least bad option:

  • buy this $80 bike from walmart and use the rear wheel from that
  • buy the cheapest new wheel ($34), freewheel tool ($8), chain whip ($9), cassette ($13), and chain ($8) from Amazon

Both options end up costing me basically the same amount, ~$75. The cheap Walmart bike option might be nice because it would give me some other spare parts. Any advice?

6
  • What kind of bike do you have now?
    – Batman
    Commented May 1, 2016 at 0:17
  • 3
    Consider why you need a new rear wheel - did you go down hard and buckle it? Your weight may come into it too, a heavier rider needs a better wheel. Walmart BSOs are not quality, you could get a better used wheel from ebay, CL, or your local bike cooperative.
    – Criggie
    Commented May 1, 2016 at 0:47
  • It's a 25 year old Schwinn hybrid, but can't remember more than that. And yeah, @Criggie, I should definitely check out my local bike co-ops for used options--that seems to be my best option.
    – mobeets
    Commented May 1, 2016 at 17:48
  • 1
    You won't get another 25 years service from a cheap wheel. Consider spending up a little, no need to go for flash expensive stuff but super-cheap is super cheap. Also, I never consider the cost of tools in a repair, because a good tool is for life and I will have them for decades. My bike tools have long-since paid for themselves.
    – Criggie
    Commented May 1, 2016 at 22:26
  • If its a hybrid, are you sure that it even uses 26" wheels?
    – Batman
    Commented May 2, 2016 at 1:06

3 Answers 3

5

First, note that if you're using indexed shifters that you need to match the number of cogs on the cassette to the shifters.

Cheap wheels are normally not worth the money -- you'll have trouble keeping them true or from failing, especially in a difficult situation like mountain biking.

On freewheels and cassette installation, I'd suggest reading this link from Park Tool.

Freewheels are used on cheaper wheels, and are only really good for <=7 speed systems. They do sell a few 8 speed freewheels, but they were essentially phased out due to axle breakage. To install a freewheel, you simply need to have some grease on the threads of the freewheel and screw on the freewheel to the hub by hand. Riding gently for a few miles will tighten the freewheel all it needs to be. To remove the freewheel, you need a freewheel remover tool (compatible with the freewheel being removed) and a large crescent wrench to turn it (or better yet, a bench vise).

For a freehub system (which uses cassettes), which is used on better 7+ speed wheels (and all 9+ speed wheels), you need the cassette tool (compatible with the cassette you're going to use) and chainwhip and a large crescent wrench to turn the tool for removing the cassette. To install it, you do not need the chainwhip.

Also, if you don't own a chain tool, you'll need one to install the chain (or at least shorten it appropriately).

My recommendation is that you look for a used wheel or a cheap wheel from your local bike shop. The parts you've selected won't work together, since cassettes only go on compatible freehubs whereas the wheel you've selected is designed for freewheels (and you've selected a freewheel). That will be a much better use of 75 dollars.

As for out of the two options you've given (not recommended), if your bike is 7 speed or less, I'd be marginally more inclined to buy the wheel and a freewheel and a small container of grease (multipurpose grease like the stuff they use for cars will work fine). If its 8 speed, and you're really on a budget, you can use an 8 speed freewheel. Otherwise, you're going to have to go with a cassette wheel, and that you have to go to the bike shop or find a wheel with a freehub. But I'd really recommend using a bike shop or spending a bit more money on a wheel, since fixing low quality wheels is not cheap at the shop (which you'd likely have to learn or pay the shop to do with such a cheap wheel), and wheel failure is not fun.

1
  • Thanks for all the advice. I'm convinced the Walmart option is not the way to go. I think I'll shop around some local bike co-ops for a replacement.
    – mobeets
    Commented May 1, 2016 at 17:46
2

The wheel by itself will likely be of much better quality, as one of the main places costs are cut when building BSOs (bike-shaped objects) is in the wheels... so you will either have a few okay bike parts and some okay tools you can re-use or a lot of worthless bike parts. Your choice.

2

As already stated by @Batman, the wheel of a Walmart bike won't be worth the effort.

Do you have a local bike co-op, or a recycle center - you can probably scavenge a wheel of an old bike?

Try to get in touch with a local cycle club or local cycle group - most cyclists I know have a selection of spares they would be more than happy to 'rehome'

Craigslist or ebay would also be a good place to look.

2
  • Most rich cyclists.
    – Batman
    Commented May 1, 2016 at 4:17
  • pfft I have a dozen spare wheels, but they're all 26" and off wrecked bikes. I don't own a single spare road wheel. That alone speaks volumes for the type of bikes that get chucked out, vs worn out.
    – Criggie
    Commented May 1, 2016 at 22:28

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.