I've just finished my first 'big' bicycle related project in order to start and complete a small challenge of at least 100 days of riding a bike in 2017 :)

This project consisted of completely disassembling full suspension (aluminum) mountain bike to the last bolt, replacing bearings, switching from press fit bottom bracket to BSA/Hollowtech (adapter which is pressed into frame), upgrading entire groupset to higher end Shimano components, messing with hydraulic brakes (shortening hoses, bleeding), installing new chain, etc.

I know this is probably ordinary thing for someone who is familiar with bikes and do this professionally, but this was my first time doing this and I'm a little concerned about safety (because I'm complete noob :) (To be specific, my biggest concerns are drivetrain, bottom bracket, chain length... as well as all other parts; except shocks for which I wasn't able to find service kits but they seem to be in good working order.) So far I've tested bike on a bike rack, I rode it in front of garage and everything seems to be working properly.

However, since I don't want to crash and hurt myself I would like to know if there is reliable way to test what I've done... something like a checklist/guidelines for assembling and testing new bike?

  • A checklist sounds useful. I would expect that no single answers covers everything. Could this be turned into a Community Wiki? Commented Dec 28, 2016 at 23:09

1 Answer 1


Revised to make a more standalone answer, rather than rely on the context given by @FalseIdentity's question, and to incorporate some of the commentary.

As with all testing, we want to find problems, so we need to do things what will discover them. But we are also the test pilot, so we have to maintain safety.

Essentially, we need to test every aspect of the bike. Even though a bicycle is quite a simple machine, the list of what and how to test is fairly long.

The first thing to do, as mentioned in the question, is to systematically check that every part seems to be properly assembled and works, while the bike is on the work-stand or still in the workshop. So, as mentioned below, check the head assembly, the front and read brakes, the front and rear gears, the bottom bracket, the wheels. At this stage we are checking that every item is properly assembled and seems to work correctly. As @Criggie says, look at and wiggle everything. I find I need to explicitly carry out this step. Many is the time I've assembled a bike and discovered something later, because I had an interruption at some point.

The next stage is test the bike by riding it. We need to maintain safety, so the first thing is to test basic brake operation. And of course we want to test basic gear operations. We'll be riding back and forth in safe environment, and so we'll be implicitly testing the steering (head set) at this stage.

The first two things to test can be done together, then move on to the others

  • Start in a low gear, and test the brakes at low speed.

  • Test the gear changes to a higher hear, go a bit faster and brake harder. Listen, watch, and feel for anything unusual.

  • As you gain confidence that the brakes are working, build up to testing them with a full emergency stop. You don't need to be going fast, just brake hard. Be sure to test both brakes. Make sure the levers have full travel and don't touch the bars.

  • Now that you know the brakes work, test all the gears, changing up and down. First without any pedaling force, then under "normal" pedaling pressure. Stop the test if they are not perfect and go back to adjust them. Also see how they feel.

  • The next test is multi gear changes. Does it change through 2 or more steps at a time. This test depends on the level of gruppo you have. Cheapies have less ability in this area.

  • If all is well keep testing under more force until you're out of the saddle and changing to higher gears with the rear derailleur. A high end gruppo should do this flawlessly. The rider risk is dropping the chain; this can be painful so take care. A good derailleur should also cope with changing down under such high pressure but this tends to be needed less.

  • The big gear test is to change both at once. Again this is only for a high end gruppo. Use low pedaling pressure and drop from the big ring to the next smaller at the same time as you change up at the back. Don't do this out of the saddle or with much pedal pressure.

  • All through these tests you must have been riding someplace safe one way and turning back. Watch for stiff or loose steering.

  • Check the saddle height. Does it feel right? Be careful in your enthusiasm that you don't set it too high.

  • Notice how the pedals feel. If they feel loose, lumpy, or grinding then go back immediately to find and cure the problem.

  • Test the suspension. First with just your own weight, then with small bumps such as kerbs, then with bigger bumps and jumps. Does it feel right? Does it damp properly? Does it recover properly?

  • If lights or computer are fitted then test them. Computer sensors can be fiddly to get right.

  • Test the bell :-)

  • 5
    If I'd realised how long that post was going to be I'd never have started it on my phone!
    – andy256
    Commented Dec 29, 2016 at 0:10
  • 1
    I'd start with more methodical looking and wiggling before getting on and riding, but that's a great list.
    – Criggie
    Commented Dec 29, 2016 at 1:26
  • 1
    Yeah, the OP says it's been tested on the stand and gently in front of the garage. But as you say, the key is to be methodical. As with all testing, we want to find problems, so we need to do things what will discover them. But we are also the test pilot, so we have to maintain safety.
    – andy256
    Commented Dec 29, 2016 at 1:50
  • 2
    I think testing the head set is essential, too. It is one of the pieces whose failure leads to a dangerous instability. Commented Dec 29, 2016 at 10:24
  • @andy256 You wrote great answer! I would add one more thing (but I'm not sure how much important is that) - what about proper tightening of bolts/parts according to manufacturer specifications? Commented Dec 29, 2016 at 21:25

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.