11

Was just wondering if a dual option like this was possible or even desirable.

4
  • 1
    I vaguely recall seeing stories of this being done on custom tandem touring bikes, back in the early days of disks. Gives each rider two brakes to manipulate, and doubles the braking ability, to compensate for the greater weight. Mar 7 '17 at 23:25
  • The Sheldon brown website with the crazy karate monkey seems to be gone :( Mar 8 '17 at 4:28
  • 2
    @whatsisname There's a picture of the Karate showing the dual brakes and levers at sheldonbrown.com/harris/surly-rohloff/images/5-frontleft.jpg adventurecycling.org/default/assets/resources/… has a similar dual handlebar setup, and mentions the Karate Monkey. More on the Thorn at sheldonbrown.com/org/thorn/index.html. That's two levers for each V-brake though, not V and disk like the Karate.
    – armb
    Mar 8 '17 at 15:44
  • if it were for redundancy, you would always have the other wheel to brake with, though it may not be sufficient to stop in time if you lose the front, since the back will lock up and skid far sooner than the front would normally have. Losing the rear is a non-issue if the rider is competent and riding in normal dry conditions, since a properly-adjusted front brake can always produce enough braking force to make the rear irrelevant (i.e. lift off the ground, and of course, you probably do not want this to happen). Aug 24 at 5:32
16

If you are asking one of each type on the bike, yes. As disc brakes were becoming popular, many companies produces bikes with a disc in the front and a rim brake in the rear.

If you are asking about one of each type on a single wheel (three or four brakes total for the bike) yes that would also be possible, but there wouldn't really be a point. Also common during the industry's transition from rim to disc brakes where frames that were designed for either. Bikes on a manufacturer's less expensive spectrum would have rim brakes and for a few hundred more, the same frame could be had with disc brakes and perhaps nicer components.

If one was to actually install a disc and rim brake on the same wheel, there would be some obstacles to overcome (assuming you wanted to actuate both brakes with the same lever). To make the brakes grip roughly the same (ie not one just one doing the work and the other making no contact) you'd have to make sure the actuation ratios or cable pull was the same for both brakes. After that you'd need to use some sort of BMX style adapter to make sure both were being pulled by the same lever. You'd also have to carefully adjust them to make sure they making contact at roughly the same time in the pull. Finally you can expect that since disc pads and rim pads probably don't wear at the same rate, all the work would have to be redone often to keep the two working in unison.

All in all you'd be paying for twice as brake for a setup that would probably work less consistently than either brake alone and require much more maintenance than either alone. If you were just wanting more stopping power, you could simply install a larger disc brake (AM or DH sized) and deal with much less setup.

EDIT: I hadn't considered the possibility of a coaster + rim or disc. Since a coaster brake would be actuated separately (by pressing back on the pedals) it could be potentially more useful and much less tinkery to maintain. That being said ANY brake should be able to lock up a wheel so it still won't gain you anything except a safety backup in the case of your primary brake (whichever you chose to use) failed.

TL;DR Possible, but not worth the effort.

5
  • 1
    I have a couple examples in my garage: an e-bikes with a front disc and rear v-brakes, and a hybrid with the capability to mount a rear disc (the next model up had discs and used the same frame but different forks). But I suspect the OP means both at once on the same wheel.
    – Chris H
    Mar 7 '17 at 21:03
  • I've seen dual-braking (rim + hub more often, but I think rim + disc exists) on Tandems.
    – CMaster
    Mar 8 '17 at 14:11
  • One other consideration you may have missed is that many disc wheels are not built with rims suitable for rim brakes. Some rims are simply not machined, others may not have a suitable braking surface or thickness where rim brakes would be applied.
    – Benzo
    Mar 8 '17 at 20:27
  • @Benzo True. Most wheels built with a disc capable hub would not have a rim brake compatible rim. This might be a bit different with road bikes, but for mountain builds is a fairly firm rule. Not to say you couldn't build a wheel that way, it's just not generally going to be easy to find a prebuilt one ready for both/either. Mar 8 '17 at 20:54
  • 1
    I purposefully built a dynamo wheel this way with disc hub and rim brake compatible rim so I could swap between different bikes. Though you could get in to spacing issues with rear hubs as well (a lot of steel frames are relatively compliant and accepting of the small amount of stretch needed to accomodate 135mm hubs)
    – Benzo
    Mar 8 '17 at 21:05
7

It's not unusual for tandems to have three brakes, with a rim brake and disc or hub brake on the same wheel. Traditionally they had a drum drag brake on the rear wheel for long descents, operated by the stoker, to avoid overheating the rims. Some modern disc brakes are up to the same job, but many aren't, though this is a subject where opinions are varied.

Tricycles often have both brakes on the front wheel, and that could be done with a disc and a rim brake.

UK law at least requires that bicycles (unlike tricycles) have braking systems on both wheels. You could have two brakes operated by one lever (as is done for some disabled cyclists), but when one brake is enough to lock the wheel, I can't see any reason to do so. (On an expedition tourer, having rim brakes fitted as a backup in case you can't get spares for a disc brake might make sense, but you would only use one at once on a given wheel. Even then, you would probably just use a frame where rim brakes could be fitted if necessary. Or just pick one.)

4

When disc brakes first appeared - a lot of mountain bikes ran with a single disc brake (mechanical) at the front and a vee brake at the rear. Whilst not ideal in terms of rear braking power or aesthetics - it's a perfectly viable option and might even make the task of fitting panniers to the rear of a bike easier.

4
  • 2
    It can actually make panniers more difficult since many rear racks pass through the area where a disc caliper would be. Many companies make a specialized rack for disc bikes since their regular racks won't fit. Mar 7 '17 at 21:37
  • 3
    @Susp: I think you mis-read the answer, which said disc brake at the front and vee brake at the rear.
    – user23374
    Mar 8 '17 at 2:43
  • @FighterJet Completely true. I am thoroughly embarrassed by my lack of reading comprehension in this case. Mar 8 '17 at 13:35
  • The opposite, with disc rear and front V, is not unknown. Thorn believe that a fork stiff enough to use a front disk compromises comfort (though they do have front disc options on some of their bikes too). cyclingweekly.com/reviews/touringaudax-bikes/thorn-mercury
    – armb
    Oct 3 '18 at 14:49
3

There would be little point to put both kinds of brakes on same wheel. No matter how hard you brake, the maximum amount of force you can apply is just before when the wheel locks. Add any more force and the wheel locks, add even more and it just keeps on being locked.

Either type of brake alone is perfectly capable of locking the wheel under normal circumstances, so there is little point to try to add any more braking force.

1
  • 1
    Thats true but only to a first approximation. Heat management in brakes is real issue in some cases as @armb's answer (added after yours) explains
    – Chris H
    Mar 8 '17 at 9:01
2

See the Merida Komfort model for rent at Finse 1222. They offer a bike with front and rear disc brakes, plus coaster (pedal) brakes. These are used on the Rallarvegen, a 53km downhill mountain bike path from 1200m elevation to sea level. With very steep sections, the triple brakes serve the purpose of redundancy.

1

I was looking for options after a disc brakes total failure incident returning from a 6 kms hill climb training, the route has a lot of traffic cars and cyclist. It was not my bike but my girlfriend's. It was a horror story and a hollywood saving life scene in a few seconds, it could've been fatal but it ended up in just a few scratches, quite lucky. the think is the mechanic who had just check the bike before the incident has no idea what failed. My idea is to have a back up rim brake in case of that total failure as the frame allows it, and may be find a hack to where to place the lever for that brake but the front wheel with disc and back with rims looks good enough to help my girlfriend get confidence on the brakes when descending again. It feels weird to find that pro cyclist had disc failure but no report either of the actual cause of the failre SEE here

5
  • 2
    The question is "can a bike have both rim and disk brakes?" and this doesn't really address that question. Can you please use edit to focus the answer to that question ?
    – Criggie
    Aug 23 at 3:52
  • I was not trying to provide an answer, It is more of an expansion to the question with my use case for having rim and disc brakes on the same bike, I thought it will contribute to the discussion. I think I can add some feedback in a few days after we adapt the bike. I think adding the experience of modified brake, the contribution will have more value to readers.
    – Danilo
    Aug 23 at 15:31
  • @Danilo If you have issues that aren't covered in the question you can ask a question yourself, refer back to this question, and include all the additional details you feel need to be covered. Please don't post follow-up questions as answers; you might want to take the tour.
    – DavidW
    Aug 23 at 17:48
  • Well, feel free to delete my post, as I tried to do it myself and could not find a way. Excuses for messing with your forum.
    – Danilo
    Aug 23 at 19:02
  • @Danilo Reading between the lines, your answer is "yes a bike can have both kinds of brakes" and once you've progresses your build, there will be some personal experiences. Those are fantastically useful, and I look forward to reading about how the bike rides. Please don't be put off by SE's somewhat strict rules - this site is quite different to a regular chatty forum, and TBH that's a good thing. You said "contribute to the discussion" and reading the tour shows that this is a Q&A format, which is quite different. Anyway - do please edit your answer with future progress.
    – Criggie
    Aug 23 at 21:11
1

My trike has two brakes on the front wheel and none at the back and my tandem has two on the rear wheel and one at the front. I can see the reasons for that. The tandem has a lot more weight to stop and has enough weight on the back wheel, even under heavy braking to stop it locking too readily. The trike needs two at the front as with the weight split between three wheels and the weight lifting off the back wheels when braking heavily means that the rear brakes would lock far too easily (and also they would be tricky to balance). I used to have an old BSA wth rod operated drum brakes and sometimes the heat build up on big descents would cause brake fade which is potentially very dangerous - I've gone round some corners far faster than I thought possible due to this. Perhaps it may be a better option to learn brake maintenance and setup rather than to simply add a spare brake to a conventional bicycle. However if a spare brake helps build confidence there would be little harm in trying it.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.