7

I'm trying to install a new bottom bracket (BB-UN55, BSA) into a new aluminum frame. Trying to screw them in by hand only allows me to go a few threads deep. On the non-drive side cup there is some thread locker that could explain the tightness a bit, but on the drive side, there doesn't seem anything that should block screwing it in by hand. I've checked the orientation of the threads on the shell and BB (CCW on drive side, CW on non-drive side), and the width of the bottom bracket (68mm).

Is this a clear case of needing to have the shell threads chased? Or could I proceed softly with a wrench without much risk of damaging the shell threads? What else could I check to make sure the frame and BB are compatible?

drive side non-drive side bottom bracket

  • 3
    +1 for a cautious approach and asking questions rather being 'that' Gorilla with a spanner. – mattnz May 31 '17 at 19:37
  • 1
    On an older bike I'd be quite suspicious of a mismatch in thread pitch, but I think they finally got that straightened out 20-30 years ago. – Daniel R Hicks May 31 '17 at 22:02
8

If one side screws in without problems, and you've verified the thread orientation, then it's not a compatibility problem. ( http://sheldonbrown.com/bbsize.html - scroll down to "bottom bracket threading".)

Trying to gently tighten it with a wrench should be fine. If you encounter abnormal resistance, then you should start thinking about taking it to a shop for chasing.

7

Maybe double-check that there is zero debris in the threads. I ran into a similar-sounding situation and it made me very nervous given the stakes. It turned out to be small bits of finely-ground rock powder in the threads. I cleaned it with degreaser, wiped it well, blew it out with compressed air, then did all that again. After, I was able to tighten it most of the way by hand as expected.

  • 1
    I tried this just now, and it was indeed a bit better after cleaning out the shell threads. I still had to screw the BB in with a wrench, and I noticed, when turning, that after it felt tight, when I kept turning, it felt loose again, up to the point where I could turn it with my hand again. My guess is that the threads of the BB and the shell are narrower at some point, and when the narrow points on both parts coincide, it gets tight... I managed to install it though, in multiple goes, checking the threads in between, and everything seemed fine. Thanks for the great anwsers! – bwindels May 31 '17 at 21:04

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.