0

I removed my 3 ring crankset from my old mountain bike and it was welded together so I have to replace the whole thing. The bottom bracket is square taper. The chainrings were 48, 38, and 28 teeth and there's an 82mm BCD. Will this crankset be ok? It seems like it might work because it's square taper (the only thing I took into account.)

https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00U1S6TVK/ref=ox_sc_act_title_1?smid=A1E5K32CINJQSZ&psc=1

  • Generally speaking, if the crankshaft interface is compatible, the crankset has the same number of cogs, and the cogs have approximately the same number of teeth, you will not have a problem. You can run into trouble if you try to upgrade from a 2-speed to 3-speed front, or if the new tooth counts are wildly different from the old, as the existing derailer may not work. And, of course, if you change tooth count you may need to adjust chain length. – Daniel R Hicks Aug 10 '17 at 22:21
  • Oh, yeah -- there's also chain width. If you're old bike has an 8 speed rear then you should be OK, but if it's 6 or 7 then the new crankset may theoretically be too thin (though it's hard to guess how this works out in practice). – Daniel R Hicks Aug 10 '17 at 22:24
  • I have a 7 speed rear cassette. The crankset on the link has 6 teeth less on each chainring than my old ones had. That doesn't sound like a big difference so I think it's ok. – matty Aug 10 '17 at 22:45
0

The BCD is irrelevant cos you're changing the whole thing. BCD only matters when you're fitting replacement chainrings in the future.

The only measurements that matter are BB interface (square taper, OK), crank length (165mm - is this suitable), and chainline (which is set more by the BB axle than the crankset)

Since you're replacing a triple with another triple, should fit fine.

However the new one is 42/32/22T and the old one is 48/38/28T so you'll probably have to remove 6 links from your chain (6 half links, or 3 wide and 3 narrow links, or 3 complete links, depending on how you want to count them.)

Also your front derailleur mech will probably need to slide down a bit, which means adjusting your front derailleur cable. May as well fit a new one while you're doing this - inners are cheap.

DO NOTE that this will make your gearing lower by ~10% so the top-speedy hard gears won't be there, and you'll have a bit more at the low end for going up steep hills slowly. Do you run out of gears at either end currently?

  • OK thanks for the advice.I think the lower gearing would help with those uphill climbs on dirt. I wanted a shorter crank too. – matty Aug 11 '17 at 3:51
  • @matty don't throw away the old one for a while in case you want to revert. I'd miss the top-end gearing for going fast, if it weren't there. – Criggie Aug 11 '17 at 9:26

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.