I run an old Raleigh Michigan that only does about 12 miles per week and lives outside a station mostly exposed to the elements. While replacing the rear derailleur cable yesterday (it had almost completely frayed through) I noticed a lot of play in the rear wheel. This must have developed over the last couple of months because I fixed a puncture about that long ago and it was OK then.

It's definitely the wheel bearings because if I tighten them the wobble goes away but the rotation becomes stiff and notchy. It's a freewheel with a 6 speed cluster and a 3/8 axle. A new hub (assuming I can get one to fit) would cost about as much as the bike is worth and I'd have to rebuild the wheel complete with rather rubbish steel rim. A new wheel wouldn't cost much more -- except it would be a freehub so I'd need a cassette (I'd get something like a tourney 7 speed and only use 6 with my existing derailleur. I'd also have to consider how to get a compatible axle.

I suspect the bike is fit only to be a donor bike or part of a frankenbike but I'm hoping I have another option.

  • Why not get a new used wheel from your local bike coop? They'd have plenty of ones with freewheels and seven gears.
    – RoboKaren
    Aug 15, 2017 at 9:08
  • @RoboKaren we don't really have one with a big stock of old parts in the city where the bike is (I might donate the bike to their training scheme). In the city where I live things are a little better but it's still more of a bike cafe/workshop and logistically tricky to get to. It would be a matter of turning up and seeing what's there. Maybe I could sprint down on a decent bike to try to pick up an old wheel or hub -- and learn to build a wheel. But your point is a valid answer even if not ideal for me.
    – Chris H
    Aug 15, 2017 at 9:40
  • Is it a threaded freewheel or freehub? 6-speed freewheels are cheap even new if the old one isn't seized in place.
    – ojs
    Aug 15, 2017 at 9:53
  • 1
    Ah, I read the question wrong, I thought it was freewheel bearings failing, not the actual wheel bearings.
    – ojs
    Aug 15, 2017 at 10:37
  • 2
    @ChrisH Actually old random cheap freewheel hubs are exactly the kind of hub you might be able to successfully use cheap generic cones and/or a generic axle set to replace. Not guaranteed but possible. Aug 15, 2017 at 18:56

2 Answers 2


A new 26" freewheel repair wheel starts at around $40US from a bike shop or Amazon, and there are also literally millions of used ones around, so even if it does need a new wheel, if it's an otherwise working bike then this shouldn't be the problem that totals it. The bike in question is old enough that it may be 126mm or 130mm in back as opposed to 135 like you'd find on most repair wheels, but that's an overcomeable problem if so, either by jamming up to a 5mm difference, respacing and redishing, or getting a 130 wheel.

As for fixing the hub, the first thing to do, before taking anything apart, is check to see how bent the axle is by spinning the left side with your hand and observing how warbly the right side is, if at all. That can easily cause a lot of resistance and bad feels in the hub, but if it hasn't been too bad too long the rest of the hardware might be usable, and a new cheap axle is only a few dollars. (Note that we're not talking about a nice one, ie Wheels Mfg. We're talking about the other kind, a generic unpackaged OEM-level replacement, which may even come with cones that may be helpful.) The next question is whether the cups and cones are totally disintegrating or just rough, i.e. heavily pitted but still have their basic shape. If the former you need cones or a new wheel if it's the cups, but if it's the latter then a new axle, new bearings, and new grease will generally be fine for a low-mileage bike.

If you do need new cones, old random freewheel hubs often use one of a couple different common basic shapes, and so cheap no-name cones often can be made to work, especially if you find a shop that has some different ones to choose from. This is actually the main application where cheap little generic "axle sets" such as the one linked to above can be useful. Determining suitable replacement cones and getting the hub properly set up with them is a larger topic; one place I know of you can read a lot about it is older free copies of Barnett's Manual floating around the internet.

Cones can be re-ground to an extent. You can get pretty sophisticated with it, but a very simple method is put the cone and a locknut on a nice straight axle in an electric drill such that the drill chuck is right against the locknut, so as the cone spins there won't be much run out. Find some kind of dowel or shaft of a diameter that matches the profile of the bearing, probably 1/4" in this case, wrap it in sandpaper or emery cloth, and clamp that in a vise. Hold the spinning cone up to it to resurface it. Go slow so it doesn't get too hot. You don't have infinite material to lose with this approach before the cone isn't the right shape anymore, but it generally works pretty well.

  • It sounds like I need to get it home and take the hub to bits then. I'm not hopeful about the cups but I won't know until I open it up. You've certainly pointed to some options I didn't know about.
    – Chris H
    Aug 15, 2017 at 20:07

In the end I did replace the bike, with something similar but newer (essentially a BSO clone of the previous one). It's not completely impossible that I'll use the old frame etc. and the new wheels, but I'm going to try out the new one first.

This proved cheaper than any option involving new parts, and saved me a fair bit of time over getting second hand parts individually.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.