4

Basically, this is the question: I can use the olives and connector inserts proper for Avid in a Shimano Deore M596 brake/hose? Has anyone tried and can report if it worked perfectly or if there was any problem? Thank you very much.

  • 3
    No idea, but if you don't get a clear and well-supported answer, just spend the money to buy the right parts. Brakes are important, and trying to economise is a bad idea. – Criggie Oct 27 '17 at 7:45
  • 2
    I second that... I've never done this or seen it done and then tested over time. The conventional thinking by both manufacturers and shops is they are in no way interchangeable. And if you just look at Shimano versus Avid, the designs of the barb and olive are way different. (Avid is stepped where Shimano has a smooth bevel.) – Nathan Knutson Oct 27 '17 at 17:03
3

No you cannot. They are not cross compatible. Shimano Olives, hose and inserts only work with Shimano components. The same is true for Avid brake equipment.

Beyond not being designed to work together you void any warranty claim by not using compatible equipment. You also give up any legal approach to the manufacturer if you use other company's parts. So if you crash because the brakes failed and want to say that's Shimano's fault and it actually was. They will say it had Avid olives and inserts on it.

  • 1
    Is this because you say so, or is there actual physical incompatibility? – ojs Jan 25 '18 at 18:49
  • they are literally different sizes and shapes. Sure you could mash and jam your way to something that resembled a working solution but why? – mbillion Jan 25 '18 at 19:34
  • 2
    So, maybe that could be a part of the answer. As for why, for example getting a good deal on one brand or having spare parts available when needed is good enough reason. There are lots of people on this site who claim that any mixing of brands is impossible, and often they are wrong. – ojs Jan 25 '18 at 19:45
  • I have worked as a bicycle mechanic for so long if I wrote an answer to reflect all of the dumb stuff I have seen people do it would be a master's length thesis every time – mbillion Jan 26 '18 at 1:12
  • regarding the comment about getting a good deal the olive and inserts are like 4-7$ usd. To me that is a horrible ROI for the thought that your brakes might stop working in traffic or the forest and you hit something immovable like a tree or car – mbillion Jan 26 '18 at 16:14
0

Yes. Used Shimano specific olive pins on my Avid Elixir 5 and Sram DB5 with no problems at all.... Been using them for about half a year now. Still holding strong. No leaks at all

  • 3
    olive pins? can you clarify if you mean olives, or connector inserts, or both? – Swifty Jul 22 at 18:48
-1

I have got a lot of shimano pins and olives here and now i switched to sram/avid HRD (Hydro road) - the prices for these olives/hoses/sets are ridicilous. So I had good look at both. shimano (brass-) olive and (stainless-) pin should work absolutely fine on sram/avid hoses. The cone of the housing/screw that actually presses the Olive onto the hose are the same (Diameter of the hose also). This only accounts for the standard (silver aluminium - black pin) avid/sram hose olive. These Red ones "stelamajjig" or whatever (i only know of etap road) - i have these here - are a bit different but i don t have the corresponding etap levers. Somwhere someone wrote that these may press a valve when mounted - with the standard ones these valves would stay closed. regards from berlin

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.