5

I have an early 2000's Giant OCR 2 roadbike (3x8 speed) with worn out chain rings on the Shimano Sora FC-3303 triple crankset. The original rings are the SG A-type, 5 bolt, 130 mm BCD in 52T-42T-30T sizes. All I can find are used ones, and I'd prefer not to change the crankset. Can I just drop the A-type originals and go with new ones in the same bolt pattern and BCD that are close (ie 53T-39T-30T)? Thanks

5

Yes, you don't have to use actual Shimano chainrings, you can use 'third party' brands.

There are a few manufacturers that produce replacement chainrings in a wide range of BCD measurements and tooth counts, so you be able to get exact matches.

If you do decide to change gearing, derailleur position and chain length will need to be changed, but you should probably be replacing the chain at the same time as as rings anyway, and also checking at the cassette for wear and replacing that if necessary.

  • Thanks, I'm replacing the chain, cassette, and rear derailleur at this point too. I've gotten several chain/cassette changes out of the bike, but the chainrings are original and are at their end of life. – coaster Jun 5 '18 at 14:39
3

Of course you can as long as the bolt pattern matches. It may happen that the new chainrings have slight offset, you would need to adjust your front derailleur then.

What will change is the gearing. Going from 52 to 53 for the largest cogring will decrease your cadence by less than 2% (will require more effort to maintain the same speed) but these are negligible values, I'd say.
You also may have to slightly rise the front derailleur, depending on how much clearance you have right now between it and the largest cog.

You should also check whether the new chainrings will fit your chain, i.e. if they are not too thick (for 1/8 chain only while your is 3/32) but I don't think it will be the case.

For your reference, I've changed the complete crank on my old 26" mountain bike. I went from 46 to 54 the largest (if I can recall) and I needed a longer chain and the front derailleur had to be readjusted for height.

0

Thanks for the help so far. The original Sora 3300 triple has always required constant adjusting, and the only chainring replacements are 9 or 10 speed which means they should work, but might not depending on variables (which chain to use, etc). It's a bit spendy, but since the frame and wheels are OK for my riding my current plan is to install a whole new Sora R3000 2x9 groupset (chain, shifters,RD,FD, cassette, crankset) for around $350 and do away with the triple altogether. If it updates key components as a set and gets me another few years of riding this bike it seems worth it.

  • If you are changing the entire group set anyway, why stick with 9 speed. I’d at least go to a 10 speed setup, as the extra gear will let you add a larger rear cog that will help offset the loss of your triple ring. – zenbike Jun 8 '18 at 12:32
  • I’d also personally consider something at the 105 level as a minimum for quality, since that is the base level for stable but current technology. The cost will be higher, but not by a great deal. – zenbike Jun 8 '18 at 12:34
  • Good advice, but the 105 is 11 speed which would mean a new rear hub. If I find a Tiagra groupset on sale I'll go with that. – coaster Jun 12 '18 at 18:53
  • An 11 speed rear wheel is cheap, relatively speaking. I’d still do 105 as best balance of cost, quality and future compatibility. But to each his own. :) – zenbike Jun 12 '18 at 19:04
0

Update: I found a very fair deal from Merlin Cycles in the UK for a Tiagra 4700 groupset (mechs, crankset,bottom bracket, brifters, cassette, chain and brakes) with my preferred choices (crank length, medium rear mech, large cassette). It came in about a week through regular post (Canada) very well packaged and complete with new cable sets. Switching a 2005 Giant OCR from Sora 3300 Triple (3x8) to Tiagra (2x10) was straightforward, just had to Amazon a Hollowtech bracket wrench as I had not used one before. The next bike will be 105 with more carbon, but this feels like a good move to keep this one at a good level, and I don't miss the Sora triple so far. It feels as good as my older Dura Ace, although I know it's heavier.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.