1

I'm building a rear wheel (my first wheel-build) that needs a 4mm dish.
How much will this amount of dish weaken the wheel?
What would be the maximum dish a wheel can have while still maintaining good strength?

EDIT:
Details:
Old and used double walled rim;
Rim outer diameter: 635mm
Rim inner diameter: 585.1mm
Rim width (measured with calipers): 24.4mm
Spoke count: 36 normal spokes
Coaster brake hub;
Hub diameter (measured between 2 opposite spoke holes): 49.1mm
Flange to flange distance: 50mm

CLARIFICATION:
By 4mm I mean dishing the wheel such that the rim moves 4mm to the left relative to the frame center line (or relative to its non-dished position). I need this because I took away 4mm worth of spacers from the drive side, and added them to the non-drive side -- effectively moving the rim+hub 4mm to the right relative to the frame center line (or relative to the drop outs).
If measured with the dishing tool (after spacer readjustment), there would be an 8mm distance between the tool point and the locknut of the non-dished wheel.

diagram showing 4mm of dish

  • 1
    Are you building anything special? I think the limit is how low the spoke tension is on the non drive side and how high it is on the drive side. If I recall correctly, with the drive side at ~1100N the non drive side is usually at ~650N which is already pretty low. Going much higher on the drive side can damage the rim and going lower on the non drive side can make the spokes go slack (which is bad). Asymmetric rims help a bit. – Michael Aug 8 '18 at 11:02
  • What hub? Is it designed for an offset rim? There are way too many variables for any real answer. You need to provided specifics such as the hub, the rim, spoke count/geometry. – Andrew Henle Aug 8 '18 at 11:22
  • @AndrewHenle You are right. I updated the question. I don't know if it's designed for an offset rim. How do I figure out? – Robert Lee Aug 8 '18 at 11:34
  • 1
    If it's symmetrical, it probably wasn't designed for any offset at all. A 4mm dish really shouldn't matter much, though. Flange to flange distance: 50mm That seems really narrow. Road bike front hubs are usually in the range of 70 mm between flanges. – Andrew Henle Aug 8 '18 at 11:42
2

It depends on what you mean by 4mm of dish. When I see that it's unclear whether you mean to say that you're respacing the flanges offset from the center by 4mm each or 2mm each. (Or in other words whether you've added 2mm or 4mm to one side and taken it away from the other).

If you took a dishless hub with same size flanges, 25mm center-to-left, and 25mm center-to-right, and then added 2mm of spacer on the right and took away 2mm on the left, (changing it to 27mm center-to-left and 23mm center to right), the free spoke calculator Spocalc says the resultant bracing angles will cause the left side tension to be 85% of the right, and the bracing angles will be 4.5º and 5.3º. Doing 4mm instead makes it 73%, with a bracing angle of 4º vs 5.5º. Mid-to-high seventy percent are what disc front wheels tend to have. Mid-forties to fifty are what conventional 11-speed road 130 hubs have, as well as Campy 8/9/10.

Basically it's a pretty minor loss of strength.

I checked Spocalc's tension numbers for this against reality once a long time ago and I remember being satisfied. I am just parroting it in this case though.

  • The question was ambiguous, I agree. I updated it with a clarification. – Robert Lee Aug 9 '18 at 2:31
  • I'm sorry, but wouldn't moving 2mm of spacers from one side to the other change the flanges to frame center line (or hub center) distances from 25-25 to 27-23? – Robert Lee Aug 9 '18 at 2:36
  • Whoops, I started writing it with different example numbers, edited. – Nathan Knutson Aug 9 '18 at 5:16

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.