3

There has been some teeth on my front chainring chipped away from knocking on some curbs. I'm thinking of buying a 1x drivetrain because I rarely change the front gear. Can I put a 1x chainring on a 3x crank? There are bolts on the cranks and I'm wondering is there a chainring that can fit in it. I have a Shimano DEORE M610 crank set. I'm doing this because I'm trying to save as much money as possible.

2

A quick google of "Shimano Deore M610" returns https://bike.shimano.com/en-EU/product/component/deore-m610.html

This shows there are 6 different cranksets in the groupset offering. Yours is a triple which excludes a couple, but your chainrings could have a mounting hole size of 104mm or 96mm for the big ring.

You need to identify your PCD or BCD dimension before buying a chainring.

We can see it needs to be a 4 hole mounting, not 5 hole.

There's nothing much to be saved by putting a 1x chainring on with its narrow/wide tooth design, because someday you will change gears by accident or on purpose, and then its a 1:1 chance your chain will go wrong when changing back to the big ring. So you could remove the left shifter and wire, and permanently lock the front mech in one point using the limit screws.

Another thought - if you only ever ride on the big ring, then your big/big combination will have the most cross-chain angle. This might be okay, or could cause premature wear on chain and chainring and cassette.

You could look at running a single chainring on your existing crank, and removing the other two for weight savings.

You could even replace the entire right crank with a single, something like the Shimano FC-M6000-B2 from the same groupset, which looks like this:

https://bike.shimano.com/content/dam/global/cg1SHICCycling/final/products/cg2SHICComponent/cg3SHICCrankset/cg4SHICCrankset/P-FC-M6000-B2_17124_1.jpg/_jcr_content/renditions/P-FC-M6000-B2_17124_1_750_750.jpeg

This appears to be a one chainring crank. You need to match the crank arm length (or change both sides) You'll also need to consider the chainline, which is how far outboard from the centerline of the bike is the chainring. On your triple it will be further out (more in line with the little cogs than the big cogs.)


For maximal frugalness, just replace the worn chainring. If you're canny and good with your hands, consider buying a used bike with the right parts, combine all the good stuff onto your bike, and give away the ratty old one or use it as a beater bike.

1

Simple answer, yes, with a few caveats.

For a 'hacked' 1x system you need to put the ring on the middle ring position not the outer position, otherwise you will be cross-chaining in lower gears at the back and accelerate wear on sprockets chain and the ring.

You need a replacement ring with the correct bolt circle diameter (BCD) and bolt pattern. The ring needs to mountable on the middle position of the crank. Some larger rings designed for mounting on the outer position will not mount properly on the middle position, because the outboard face of the ring is is not flat.

You'll need replacement short chainring bolts as you will be attaching a single middle ring not a middle and outer (inner ring has separate bolts).

Dedicated 1x systems use a 'narrow-wide; chainring for better chain retention. If you get a cheaper plain ring leave the front derailleur in place and adjust the limit screws so that it acts as a chain guide, otherwise there us a risk of the chain coming off the chainring on bumps.

  • Not every 1x chainring requires a new set of chainring bolts. For example, RF chainring works both with short and long bolts, I used one with FC-M610. – Klaster_1 Nov 13 '18 at 14:06
  • IS there a chainring you can recommend me that can fit mine? maybe like an example – Lam Munn Juan Nov 15 '18 at 12:35
  • @LamMunnJuan Product recomendations are off topic here, one reason being differences in availability of products in different countries. I'm not aware of what's available in Malaysia. It also depends on what size you want. Maybe a good place to start is Shimano's own rings for this crank. – Argenti Apparatus Nov 15 '18 at 12:56

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.