1

The Sora 2x derailleur mech that came with my gravel bike broke in half. Is the 2x Tiagra/105 front derailleur compatible with the R3000 shifters? Thanks!

2

You can get the Shimano specs and compatibility info here (expand Technical Documents on left hand side).

The front drivetrain compatibility chart says the ST-R3000 lever is only compatible with the FD-R3000 front derailleur.

If you study the compatibility chart you'll see there tends to be a lot of compatibility between drivetrains that match in number of speeds, but not between speeds. For instance 2x10 Ultegra 6700, 105 5700 and Tiagra 4700/4600 are all compatible with each other but not 2x9 or 2x8 group components.

Update:

I recalled a question where the asker had a Trek bike with a Sora drivetrain and 105 front derailleur. Obviously Trek thinks this works and Shimano are known to be conservative in their specifications and compatibility recommendations.

  • 2
    But if you already own the FD in question you could always give it a try. – Carel May 24 at 17:10
  • 2
    4700 Tiagra isn't compatible with any older 10 speed groupsets as they changed it to be like the 5800/6800/9000 11 speed groupsets. Officially, it's only compatible with 4700, but the FD works with Shimano 11 speed shifters. – Carbon side up May 24 at 21:11
  • Any Shimano road shifter 10 speed and below (except Tiagra 4700) works properly on any Shimano derailleurs designated 9 speed and below. This includes designated mountain mechs. Obviously a 10s road shift will work with a 10s road derailleur, but things get too different here as mountain 10 speed systems (DynaSys) significantly changed the length of cable pull/derailleur movement. Also, some older duraAce series can only be used together. Spacing of the cassette sprockets differ as the number of them increase, so that's involved too but derailleurs don't know or care what "speed" they are – Jeff May 26 at 1:41
  • @jeff That's true for rear derailleurs, because it's known that Shimano used a 1:1.7 actuation ratio for MTB 9 and below and road 10 and below. Front derailleurs are a different matter. I've never seen any comprehensive information on their actuation ratios and cable pulls. – Argenti Apparatus May 26 at 10:39
  • @Argenti Apparatus I've found in practice that the front shifting systems are less finicky than rear. For instance, my Giant mtb front end, combined a Deore 9 speed shifter--a left 3 speed actually, SL-590, controlling a Shimano 7 speed/triple front mech (model number in the 100's) perfectly. Now I have no probs after changing to a Deore FD-M611, which is marketed as 10 speed. My Stumpjumper got a new 10 speed triple crankset (FC-622) which meshes perfect with the stock 9 speed system. I did assume the same relationship exists up front that is documented for the rear, but maybe not. – Jeff May 26 at 11:31

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.