A couple different shops have suggested that it’s time to replace my drivetrain. Chain has stretched and gears are losing shape. The rear cassette is an SRAM PG-950 12-26 9 speed. Crank is Tiagra 30/39/50.

Question is whether I replace the drivetrain apples to apples or use this as an opportunity to upgrade? I’m not sure what I could upgrade without also having to change the tiagra shifters or derailleurs. But I want to keep investing in this hike.

I use it mostly for commuting with the occasional 20 or 30 mile weekend ride (I replaced the stock tires with 28mm Armadillos). I climb hills and often use the 30-26 combo and could use something even more helpful.

  • 1
    Budgetweise, you can either replace drivetrain or entire groupset but there are so many differences between 2009 and now that nothing in between really works. You can install a wider range cassette in your current setup. Armadillos have terrible rolling resistance, of you want to make the bike easier to ride the first step is to replace them with something better.
    – ojs
    Aug 31 '19 at 6:58
  • Continental makes good tires in general. Their Gatorskins are durable. I suspect these will have less rolling resistance than Armadillos, and they may be worth investigating.
    – Weiwen Ng
    Aug 31 '19 at 12:03

Personally I am a fan of a regular, low cost maintenance,regime and not a fan of 'upgrading for upgrade sake - its a great way to overspend because you inevitably throw away perfectly good parts. A 2009 bike with 12Speed drive train might be better than original, but it is not a 2019 bike. If you sell the old bike and take the upgrade money and put it into a new bike, you will often end up with a better bike.

9 Speed is pretty good for longevity and lack of maintenance. Replacing whats worn will be cheaper - probably only chain, cassette and maybe chainrings. If you decide to stay with 9 speed you should still be able to get parts for many years and there are 3rd party manufacturers making some very cost effective 9speed parts (Microshift).

The other option is replace the entire drive train, which adds the cost of shifters, derailleur, and to make it worth while, chain rings and maybe cranks and front shifter.

I would only consider replacing the entire drive train if the bike was failing to meet some requirement - not enough gear range, too much spread between shifts etc. If you have big hills to climb, strong winds to battle and you are reaching for a lower (or higher) gear, it may be time for an upgrade.

Ultimately the question comes down to you budget, and tolerance for spending money. There is no need to spend money for an upgrade, if you want to spend the money, go for the upgrade.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.