1

I'm interested in converting my front crankset from 3 to 1 for simplicity.

I'm not sure where to start or what size to obtain? This is what I have... 18" Carrera Vulcan, 27.5 x 2.2, 2016.

Do I use a large or small crankset? How do I know the teeth measurement?

Do I need a chain guard or does a crankset takes care of preventing chain from falling off?

Thank you for your time

1

If you now have a triple front chainring, the best position for new a single chainring replacement would be the middle position on your current crank. It will likely to give you the best chainline for the extreme rear cassette positions (the smallest and the biggest rear cogs).

Regarding the number of teeth, it is up to you to decide, but use your existing middle ring tooth count as a starting point. E.g., if your current front rings are 42/32/24, the middle ring has 32 teeth. The new chainring should have 32 teeth or less if you often run steep uphill, or 34−36 if you focus on fast downhill. Note that if you do not feel comfortable using only your current middle front chainring (e.g. only using rear derailleur to change gears) already now, it means that the range of your present rear cassette would not be wide enough for you when you switch to a single front chainring. In this case, consider getting a wider range cassette as well. Be sure to match BCD on new and old stuff.

If you plan to get a new chainring which is marketed to prevent chain drops (often called "narrow/wide" chainrings), and/or if you have a rear derailleur with clutch, you may be fine without a chain guard (still recommended for riding rough terrain though). If you plan to get an old-school (cheaper) plain chainring meant to be used in single-speed drivetrains or one with ramps for front derailleur, you'll definitely need a chain guard.

  • Thank you very much, Grigory for your patience to write up a fantastic explanation regarding replacing a chainring. I feel more confident to do the right thing. – MrRoberts Sep 7 at 16:23

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.