2

I'm kinda new for this, I am planning upgrade my bike from a freewheel type to a cassette type. How can I determine the cogs for the cassette type? My old bike has 8-speed freewheel cogs gears which range from 13T-28T.

  • An 8 speed freewheel is not impossible but its quite uncommon. By the time 7 speed was common, the flaws of the freewheel hub were well-known. Is your bike worth the upgrade costs? – Criggie Nov 16 '19 at 21:40
  • Perhaps if you explained why you feel the need to "upgrade". – Daniel R Hicks Nov 17 '19 at 20:58
4

You need same number of speeds, same cog spacing and freehub body splines splines. If you don't have any specific need to change the range, you can pick the same sizes. If you want to change the range, there are plenty of answers about that on this site.

For cog spacing and splines, there are two common ones for 8-speed: one for Campagnolo and other for Shimano and everything else. Unless you have a road bike with Campagnolo, you can just pick any 8-speed cassette that is not advertised as Campagnolo compatible.

1

ojs's answer has already covered the mechanical compatibility issues.

If you're asking about how to get the same gear ratios, basically any 13-28T cassette will have the same, or nearly the same, gear ratios as the one you already have. Essentially, the ratios are chosen to give as even a sequence of gears as possible, and the only real scope for differences is in deciding how to round the "ideal" ratios, which will be fractional numbers, into physically achievable integer numbers of teeth.

Another possible design decision is to have the largest cog quite a bit larger than the second-largest, to give a "granny gear" for steep hills. However, such a cassette would have a largest cog with more than 28 teeth, so you don't need to worry about that. A typical such set up might be the equivalent of a normal seven-speed 13-28T cassette, plus a 34T largest cog.

  • Another question, If I am to consider upgrading to 10-speed cogs, do I need to change the crankset as well or just the rear gears and shifter. I have an existing 3speed crankset that have come along with my 8-speed. I can't quite grasp the compatibility of the parts yet. Thank you for your response by the way. – Arjay Volante Santiago Oct 26 '19 at 16:29
  • @ArjayVolanteSantiago Yes, you probably need a new crank. 8, 9, 10 and 11 speed chains get progressively narrower and sprocket and chainring spacing is reduced. Conventional wisdom is that you can have a crank one speed different, but not two. – Argenti Apparatus Oct 26 '19 at 16:37
  • 4
    @ArjayVolanteSantiago Bear in mind that if you are replacing the rear wheel, crankset, cassette, chain, derailleurs and shifters , that's a significant part of the bike. A whole new bike can be more cost effective and everything is upgraded. – Argenti Apparatus Oct 26 '19 at 16:43
  • @ArjayVolanteSantiago: at that point you're approaching the en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ship_of_Theseus It will be wiser to just get another bike at that point 99 times of ouf 100. – whatsisname Oct 26 '19 at 17:49

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.