1

I would like your pro advice with a bike upgrade.

Please refer for details: Specialized Hardrock Disc SE 26 (2014) Specs Why the upgrade?

  1. 5-year-old shifters, displays are cracked up and yellow.
  2. Because I keep replacing my front shift cable, I service my left shifter often. In doing so, I ground up one of the screw heads - now unserviceable.

Other considerations:

  1. Rear cassette is showing signs of wear, and I plan to replace the stock 7 speed with a 9 speed cassette instead.
  2. Can the existing 7 speed rear derailleur, Shimano Tourney, handle a 9 speed cassette?

New shifter:

  1. Easily serviceable. Better screws than Tourney.
  2. A smaller display, so that wear doesn't show, unlike Tourney.
  3. A shifter-brake combo is preferable.
  4. Shimano 7 or 9 speed, trigger type.

My conception: new 3x9 shifters, new 9-speed rear cassette, same old Tourney rear derailleur.

Do you replace your front shift cable often? I shift a lot, is this why mine keeps wearing out? I'm on my 4th/5th shift cable, it shreds itself near the pinch bolt.

Please advise on the best course of action. I appreciate your help!

U404BioMaster

  • Remember Tourney is the lowest grade of component available retail in the Shimano line. Its not great. I have used a 6 speed tourney rear mech in an 8 speed config, and it shifts acceptably though a better mech would be lighter, more accurate and generally nicer. – Criggie Dec 21 '19 at 22:50
  • I'd save on a front mech and convert to 1x9 instead. My friend has recently done this to an old trek 4300 using Microshit rear mech - a bit cheaper than comparable Shimano one. – k102 Dec 24 '19 at 9:26
3

Two issues with what you are proposing:

The splined freehub body that the cassette slides onto on the hub were narrower on a 7 speed drivetrains than later 8, 9 or 10 speed drivetrains. See this Sheldon Brown page.

You might have a 8/9/10 speed compatible hub with a 7 speed cassette and 4.5mm spacer. If that's the case you can upgrade to 9 speeds. If not you either have to get a new rear wheel, hack the cassette (link to details on the Sheldon Brown page) or stick with 7 speed.

The 7 speed Tourney derailleur will nominally work with a 9 speed cassette and shifter, because Shimano rear derailleurs use the same actuation ratio (ratio of cable pull to lateral cage movement) for 7 through 9 speed MTB derailleurs. However, you will be compromising a 9 speed system with a lower quality Tourney derailleur. Do the upgrade properly with front and rear shifters and derailleurs.

Don't forget that you'll need a 9 speed specific chain.

Your current 3 chainring crank should work OK but the shifting might not be the best. Of course a crank from a 3x9 speed group will be lighter and shift better.

| improve this answer | |
  • Thank you, from the complexity of the task at hand, I've decided to replace my shifters, retaining the original drivetrain. – U404 Bio Master Dec 22 '19 at 6:43

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.