6

The bike I use to commute - a cheap, no brand city bike - is unbalanced, and naturally leans to the right. This is not noticeable normally, but it's enough to make riding without the hands on the bars requires quite some effort to avoid drifting right.

Of course I can't just ask you what the cause is, but could you help me in finding it? What should I look for/test/check?

6
  • 2
    Get a rack, put single pannier on left. Problem Solved :)
    – Kibbee
    Oct 20, 2011 at 16:12
  • 2
    Why are you riding with no hands on a commuter bike? Please don't tell me it's because you have to answer your cel phone. Oct 20, 2011 at 16:22
  • 6
    He likes to juggle to pass the time. Oct 20, 2011 at 18:02
  • Oh, okay. That sounds safe enough. Oct 20, 2011 at 19:40
  • 1
    @lawndartcatcher absolutely not! Cell phone is always with wired or bluetooth headset. The reason I tried riding without hands was only to check for the bike balance - I don't do it usually.
    – Agos
    Oct 21, 2011 at 9:58

8 Answers 8

7

a) Is the headset tight? Over time that can loosen up and it'll start to lean in one direction or the other (usually based on which side of the pothole you just hit).

b) Are your wheels true? this probably won't make a major difference but it might combine with the previous point.

c) Is the weight on the bicycle evenly distributed? E.g., do you wear a messenger bag across your left shoulder so the weight of the load pulls the bike in that direction?

d) Does this happen in a parking lot as well as on the road? Don't forget that streets aren't flat - they curve off to the edges to allow water to shed from the roadway (and into nice deep puddles for motorists to drive through and splash cyclists). If it only happens on the road (and you always ride on the right hand side of the road) it's probably because of Gra-vi-ty.

4
  • Thanks for the suggestions. Some more details: no difference (no bags, I go with a backpack). I thought about road shape, but it happens on flat surfaces as well. Of course the effect is even more on curved roads.
    – Agos
    Oct 21, 2011 at 22:38
  • It turned out there was a difference in weight. A tiiiiny magnet from an old bike computer was still on the spokes, and when I removed it (all 6 grams of it) the problem fixed itself.
    – Agos
    Oct 23, 2011 at 22:27
  • 3
    @Agos : do you actually MEAN IT when you say the problem was a 6 gram magnet, and the problem went away because you removed it? No offense, but I doubt it very, VERY much... Oct 25, 2011 at 18:23
  • @heltonbiker I know it sounds implausible. I can't be sure, since I did some other work on the bike the same day (moved the bell, removed CPU support, removed bottle holder, installed new lock holder, etc.), but that was the only really out of axis thing I touched. I should try putting it back on to see what happens :)
    – Agos
    Oct 25, 2011 at 21:58
6

First check that the handlebar is actually square to the front wheel.

Next check that the seat is straight relative to the top bar.

Stand in front of the bike, straddling the front wheel, and sight down the top tube. Verify that there is no twist in the frame causing the front steering tube to not be in line with the seat tube. Check the fork and frame for any other obvious out-of-alignment problems. (Note that a frame can be straightened if it's slightly bent.)

Then check to be sure that neither of the crank arms is bent (a common problem with bikes that are frequently dropped on their sides). Also make sure neither of the pedal shafts is bent.

3

Since the headset bearings tend to be always around the same position while riding (because the headset does not spin, except for those performing barspins), and we rarely disassemble them, sometimes the spheres create depressions on the bearing tracks. This creates a "stable" position when the front wheel is pointing straight ahead, but sometimes this self-centering is to another (non-straight) position.

To check this problem, lift the bike from the top tube in normal riding position, and try to gently take the handlebar slightly away from this position. If the bike tends to "self align", the most probable cause is this "marked" headset. Fully disassemble and clean the bearings to perform a visual inspection is the only way to be 100% sure.

To solve the problem, these sequential steps should be taken. If the former step didn't solve, go on to the next:

  1. Loosen the headset just a little bit, letting it tightened just enough to prevent play when braking. This solves the problem sometimes;
  2. Open it (no need to disassemble) just enough you can spin the spheres out of position. Do this for the upper and lower bearing;
  3. Fully disassemble (including remove the cups from the frame), clean and remount in a different position;
  4. If neither of these solves, replace the headset for a new one.

EDIT: take away the handlebar and perhaps the front brake, and perform some barspins, to reorient the spheres. This could be the "Step 1.5"

Hope it helps

2

One possible cause that I'm missing from the other answers is wheel alignment: When your bike steers straight, are both wheels exactly in the same plane? If not, this might be the cause. I would turn the bike upside down, and look flat over the top of the rear wheel to check this. If the front wheel track appears not to be dead center of the rear wheel track, the wheels are not perfectly aligned.

Causes for a suboptimal wheel alignment can be:

  • Rear wheel is not straight within its dropouts, especially horizontal dropouts may produce a heavy misalignment.

  • Rear wheel is not dished correctly. This puts the plane of the wheel outside the center line of the frame, and very likely out-of-plane with the front wheel.

  • Frame is warped.

Of course, the front wheel could also be the culprit, but since it's not dished and does not have slit dropouts for adjustment, this is unlikely.

1

Has the bike been in an accident recently? Your frame might be skewed as a result. Happened to me, with the exact same symptom. After careful checking it turned out the top tube was slightly bent in one place.

This happened in the days of steel frames, though. An aluminum or carbon frame is more likely to break than to bend.

2
  • No accidents until now, luckily!
    – Agos
    Oct 21, 2011 at 22:42
  • Not just the frame - any fork damage can cause strangeness too. I had a steel road bike where the steering was off, the reaction under hard braking was terrifying, and later I realised that the front wheel followed a different track to the back wheel, even when straight ahead. The whole fork was subtly twisted and bent.
    – Criggie
    Jun 6, 2021 at 1:06
1

How much lean are we talking about? I jokingly said that you should ride around with a single pannier. However I ride around like this all the time, and if there isn't much in the pannier (pump, some spare tubes, a couple of small tools), I can easily ride with no hands.

I would check that your wheel is actually properly set in the hub. I know on my bike it's possible to do up the quick release without the wheel properly seated. However the few times that I've done it, I noticed right away because the wheel rubs on the brakes. You should spin the wheels and ensure that the distance between the brake pads and the rims stays constant as it turns. If it doesn't you either got warped rims, or the wheel isn't mounted right.

1

I've been having this problem too. Read and read these forums looking for solutions. Been riding on schwalbe tires for 2+ years so figured I was due for new ones.

My answer was to put on "land cruiser" tires and problem is solved!

I'm so freaking happy! The center of old tires were unevenly flat due to always riding on right side of road, hence heavily leaning to the right. Definitely got my money's worth on the old marathon plus tires. 2+ years of serious commuting and not one flat.

1
  • 1
    Welcome to the site - I've taken the liberty of tweaking the working a bit to highlight the answer, otherwise it read as a "me too" kind of reply. Great work getting your issue solved, would have been good to see if flipping the tyres helped at all. To be fair, many tyres are marked "directional" but its not a big deal on a bicycle to run them backwards.
    – Criggie
    Jun 6, 2021 at 8:30
0

Had this problem myself and fixed it by tightening the quick release mechanism on my front wheel; which I mean tightening the two nuts that hold the mechanism in the wheel.

1
  • Welcome to Bicycles SE. We're looking for answers with more detail. Please consider expanding your answer to explain why this caused your bike to lean, as well as adding in other possible causes of the problem. A short, one-line answer like this is likely to get downvoted, flagged for moderator intervention, and possibly deleted.
    – jimchristie
    Jul 5, 2016 at 15:39

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.