1

My most recent bike was a Trek Domane SL6 that I loved, but the frame has started to show some cracks and I am looking at switching over the Shimano Ultegra components to a steel frame.

I am a big guy, 220 lb (100 kg) at my fighting weight so bike weight isn't a big concern. The bike will be used mostly on the road for bi-weekly 100+ mile (160 km) rides and the occasional long distance group ride. (I also might do a triathlon later this year but I am not looking to podium, just finish.) It will also be used to ride for fitness and fun, not really any commuting.

I have been looking at the Mason Definition 2 frame as well as some of the All-City frames. Does anyone have any experience with these two companies?

The bike will also be used, on weekdays, on a Wahoo Kickr trainer for workout purposes and to build up endurance.

The Domane is my only experience with modern bikes so I am not sure what else I should look at or avoid, so any help would be greatly appreciated.

Improve this question
2
  • 1
    Welcome to the site! I'd recommend checking this existing post out and describing what questions you still have after reading it here How can you recognise a quality steel frame?.
    – dpollitt
    Mar 3 '20 at 4:30
  • 2
    Trek does offer lifetime warranties to the original purchaser, so if the frame really is cracked, you could do that. Even if you want a steel frame instead, you’d be better off taking and selling the warranty frame.
    – Weiwen Ng
    Mar 3 '20 at 10:53
2

Buying a frame to build up when you don't have much experience is tricky because you cannot test ride frames alone. Most importantly you want to make sure you will get a good riding position fit. If there is a bike store that sells complete bikes with the frames you want try test riding those.

If you cannot test ride frames in this way then you need to look at the geometry. You can basically split geometry into the cockpit dimensions: stack and reach, and the handling: head tube angle, fork offset, chainstay length and front-center. You can use the Domane as a reference point. If you liked the riding position look for a frame with similar stack and reach and remember you can adjust riding position by getting a longer or shorter stem. Longer chanstays and slacker head tube angle will give you a more stable but slower turning bike.

Some other considerations. Most steel frames will have a threaded bottom bracket shell. The Domane has a pressfit bottom bracket (BB90 I think). Shimano cranks with 25mm axles will fit in external threaded bottom bracket cups but I think you will want to get a frame with a 68mm road bottom bracket shell width to fit the road crank axle length. (You can check the specs of you crank here.)

Improve this answer
2
  • Head tube height can also be important, especially for someone who's going to use the bike in a triathlon. A tall head tube will preclude a low aerodynamic bar position.
    – Andrew Henle
    Mar 3 '20 at 12:47
  • @AndrewHenle Stack takes that into account. Obviously a long head tube will produce a higher stack.
    – Argenti Apparatus
    Mar 3 '20 at 12:57
2

Contentious opinion: get whichever bike has a paintjob you like more. Both are going to be fine bikes.

With that said, All-City's frame have a pretty wide variety of component restrictions, e.g. some have press-fit BBs, some don't, their new Zig-Zags are through-axle, older ones aren't, etc. So, if you plan to use your existing parts you'll have to closely scrutinize the mechanical specs or you may run into trouble that way. I don't have any familiarity with Mason's lineup so no idea if you'd have the same problems.

Additionally, I'd echo Argenti Apparatus' concerns about sizing. The simple fact that you are asking this question means you haven't encountered the hassle of mixing and matching bike components around, and don't have a boatload of spare parts in a tub you can go to to fine tune fitting after getting a bare frame. So, I think you'd be better off just getting a new complete bike, one you can test ride before you buy it. It'll probably be cheaper too.

Then just leave your trek permanently hooked up to the trainer.

Improve this answer

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.