One of my most useful bicycles is my 58cm 700c Xtracycle based on a Novara Xpresso cyclocross style frame. Lately, as the kids are getting bigger and my back isn't getting any younger: I crave a much lower top bar. I would consider a used mixte frame, a step-through frame, or other really low diamond frame. Recommendations for sturdy and faithful frame models appreciated. Ability to handle 3 rings and 8 cogs plus a chain stay bridge preferred.

These areas would help me evaluate the frames I might find:

  • Stability: I have heard some people mutter that mixte frames are "unstable" as donor frames. Is this substantial? (I get some shimmy and flex in my present Xtracycle but I'm running a cro-moly frame but it doesn't bother me.)

  • Fit: Is there a more limited range of geometry among these frames? Could I find frames like these around 56-58cm or about 19.5 inches? If it is a large "WSD" style frame, how much difference does that make for a male pilot?

  • Strength: Are frames with lower top bars any weaker? Steel is not a requirement, but I expect to load it up with camping gear and elementary school age kids.

1 Answer 1


Have a look on the second hand market for 'Giant Trail' mountain bikes from a few years ago. These had an unusual frame design with a lower top tube, wider, more stable bars and disc brakes. Giant Rincon Trail, Giant Boulder Trail were a couple of the affordable models I remember.

enter image description here

  • That's not an "unusual frame design". Other than the little curve between top tube and seat tube it's a standard mixte frame. The frame is quite strong, and in fact has a reputation for being stiffer than a diamond frame -- almost too stiff. Was a popular BSO youth "mountain bike" frame for a couple of decades before the fancy suspended frames took over that market. Nov 14, 2011 at 12:21
  • Trek makes a few bikes with this style frame, one such model is the Neko (trekbikes.com/us/en/bikes/town/dual_sport/neko/neko/#)
    – Kibbee
    Nov 14, 2011 at 14:00
  • I like this frame design, and I like the Neko's frame design. They make me think that should look at early 29er frames because I don't need disk. However the market on hardtail 29er frames seems pretty slim. Dec 2, 2011 at 18:19

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.