2

What is the difference between: single speed freewheel Shimano SF MX 30 and Shimano SF-1200 ?

Why those freewheels donesn't appear on shimano website?

P.S. From the pictures it's clear that the removal tools are different.

SF-1200 SF-MX30

4

The removal tool is the main difference. The one on the right is a more widely used fitting, and this is the tool you would want.The design on the left is more hassle to remove, so most companies use the other style now. Regarding your other question about freewheels, this MX 30 is a fine component, but the White Industries freewheels have a cartridge bearing and the ratchet has more points of engagement and is easier to service, etc. Well worth the money for the lifespan of a component like this.

1
  • "White" freewheel costs 100 - 125$ ?!.... Instead of 15-30 for Shimano... – Michael D Jun 25 '20 at 12:13
1

Googling for "specs shimano sf-mx30" leads to a lot of hits from bike resellers, but none from shimano.com which confirms your findings.

The sf-1200 seems to be 16 tooth only, but the sf-mx30 is available in 16/17/18 tooth options.

Both are for 1/8" chain and both fit a standard freewheel mount of 1.370x24 tpi.

I suspect the main differences come down to tolerances and build quality. The black mx30 has far less of a "china-BSO" appearance than the 1200, and various reviews suggest that the mx30 is more reliable. You should search those out and compare yourself.

Though ultimately, what you get depends on availability.... if it is not in stock you can't have it and will have to settle or wait.

3
  • @Crigie, It seems me from few shops specs, that SF-1200 is for 1/8 chain and SF-MX30 is for 3/32 chain. Does it meaningful? – Michael D Jun 25 '20 at 18:09
  • 1
    @MichaelD I didn't mention 3/32 because there was no obvious consistency in the results. Most sites said 1/8" and only one said the mx30 was for both widths. It's certainly possible. The only info on shimano.com is that the mx30 tool is Y12009150 TL-FW45 and the sf-1200 tool is Y1200904T TL-FW40 – Criggie Jun 25 '20 at 21:56
  • 2
    Which ever style you go for, don't forget to put ample grease on he hub threads before mounting it. – bradly Jun 26 '20 at 0:39

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.