1

So, I have the Shimano shifter, depicted below that selects from the 7 rear-wheel sprockets.

To my surprise it no longer reaches highest nor lowest gear.

At first I thought the cable could have lost tension, but that is not the case. Also, if it were the case, I would expect it not to reach lowest, but easily reach highest.

What is going on with a shifter if it can't reach the extreme positions anymore? It used to work just fine.

Shimano shifter side-view

Shimano shifter rear-view

3
  • 2
    Could be the limit screws. Jul 10 '20 at 1:04
  • @DanielRHicks seems unlikely that limit screws would adjust themselves Jul 10 '20 at 14:15
  • Have you done anything to adjust the bike? Been in any wrecks? Did you notice shifting getting progressively more difficult, or did you take the bike out one day and it suddenly wouldn't shift?
    – Adam Rice
    Jul 10 '20 at 15:28
3

Common reasons for a derailleur not getting to the low gears (larger sprockets) is the shift cable slipping through the pinch bolt that secures it on the derailleur, cable housing has come out of shifters or frame stops or bad adjustment via the barrel adjusters.

The common reason for a derailleur not getting to the high gears (smaller sprockets) is the cable hanging up in the cable housing and preventing the derailleur spring from moving the cage outwards.

First follow the cable run from the shifter to the check the cable housing is properly inserted in the shifter and all frame stops.

Detach the cable from the derailleur, tension the cable by pulling on it with a pair of pliers, work the shifter and make sure it shifts through all gears and pulls in and lest out the cable smoothly. If the cable does not move through the housing smoothly take the cable out and wipe it off, if you still have problems replace the cable and housing.

With the back wheel of the ground, manually pedal and carefully push the derailleur cage in to make sure it will move between the smallest and largest sprockets. If the derailleur range is too limited check the limit adjustments and look for anything jamming the parallelogram.

Reattach the shift cable and follow a guide for derailleur set up and adjustment. Park Tool has a really good one.

Cleaning the chain, derailleur jockey wheels and sprockets and re-lubing the chain will help also.

1

If you don't have it, download a Shimano rear derailleur manual and follow the procedure for adjusting the limits, or follow one of the many Youtube videos, like this one

. The process is the same for most models. The limit screws control how far the derailleur moves in or out.

1

First thing you should do is undo the bolt that's holding the shift cable until it's completely loose. Then adjust the H screw until it sits perfectly on your highest gear.

Once you have that, then you should screw in the barrel adjuster on your handle bars all the way to the right.

Next, reattach the shift cable bolt to hold the cable tension; you want to hold the cable taught when you're screwing it in. Not too tight, but not too loose.

From there try to shift up - if there's not enough tension / it's not shifting, just twist the barrel adjuster to the left. This will tighten the cable to allow the derailleur to shift properly.

Once it is shifting up and down consistently, it will most likely undershoot or overshoot the lowest gear. Adjust the "L" screw until it sits in the lowest gear. You also want to check that it's not going to over shift into the spokes of your rim, so it's safer to go closer to inwards than outwards. (Your bike has a protector for that, so I don't think it is possible to shift into your spokes).

Lastly, you might get some inconsistent shifting somewhere in the middle of the cassette. Shift to the lowest gear, and make sure that between the derailleur hanger cog and the gear that there's about a pinky length between them touching. You don't want it too far apart and you don't want it to touch the cassette.

If you're still getting inconsistent shifting, try small increment / decrement of barrel adjuster tension.

If that doesn't work, you either have a bent derailleur hanger or the incorrect derailleur for your cassette. You should be able to Google this information pretty easily based on the model of your derailleur.

If the derailleur came on your bike new, you can basically phase out the possibility of it being the wrong derailleur.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.