I've checked the hanger and that seems solid. There is some movement/wobble in the derailleur at the bolt that connects it to the hanger, like it's not quite tight enough even though it's tightened as far as it will go. When followed down to the cage it feels like 1-2mm in sideways cage movement, maybe more - it feels significant anyway. The cage itself is definitely still solid on the derailleur, and it lines up straight under all of the sprockets.

I took the derailleur off, cleaned the threads and everything around them including the c-clip, refitted but still some wobble. I think it's affecting my shifting as the cage might not necessarily return to the exact same place at the extremes of the cassette meaning I can't find a cable tension that works for all gears.

Is there anything else I can check before trying a new derailleur? (I have a medium cage ready to go but the current short cage has been working fine so reluctant just to retire it)

I did notice that around the c-clip it wasn't an entirely flat surface, there were a few metallic ridges the were higher around the edge than other parts of the surface. Are they there for a reason and do they have to be located in a certain place? It's a Tiagra derailleur, looks pretty much like this: https://i.stack.imgur.com/LsyF4.jpg

1 Answer 1


I think you cannot do anything with this wobble. I have similar one, opened the derailleur, but inside I just found out that the part that goes around that bolt inside is probably slightly deformed. It is a metallic cylinder - a hole that goes around the bolt, but when it becomes deformed to be slightly wider, it just causes some play of the derailleur on the hanger.

You can test whether my description fits your situation by wiggling the derailleur and looking what actually moves. In my case the bolt and the flat metallic part connected to it stay firmly connected to the hanger and what moves is the actual body of the derailleur (painted).

  • Thanks - did it affect the shifting in any way? Is 1-2mm of play at the bottom of the cage enough to make indexing difficult/impossible? Either way I'll try the new derailleur and see if that solves everything.
    – Wilskt
    Mar 7, 2021 at 21:54
  • I did have some strange noises at the time that prompted me to investigate it. However, mine is an 8-speed RD so it is not that sensitive as 10-speed RDs. Mar 7, 2021 at 21:58

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.