I mashed my 8 speed Shimano Acera rear derailleur in a crash over the weekend and need to get it replaced. Is it worth spending a little extra money and installing a slightly higher-end derailleur, such as a Shimano Deore or Alivio derailleur, or does it not really make all that much difference without replacing the whole drivetrain? (Which I am not willing to do) The bike is relatively new so the other componentry is in good condition if this is a consideration. Thanks

  • 2
    In this situation I go to a couple of my favorite online sites, click buttons for the derailer (Shimano 8speed, long cage etc), and choose the one that I can afford on biggest discount. If you are lucky, you will get an XT for less than an Alivio.... (That is how my kids 20" wheel bike ended up with an XT)
    – mattnz
    Jun 15, 2021 at 7:50
  • Can you even get a new Deore derailleur which is 8 speed compatible? In any case the differences will be small. The most important aspect for shifting is friction in the cables. Better spend the money on good, new cables+cable housing if/when they are worn. Also make sure your derailleur hanger is straight.
    – Michael
    Jun 15, 2021 at 12:26
  • For 8 speed you can do better price/performance than Shimano. Brands such as Microshift offer a range of products, some $himano compatible.
    – mattnz
    Jun 16, 2021 at 0:52

1 Answer 1


Any 8 speed derailleur should work fine - the higher the "grade" the better made they are.

However the incremental difference is slight, and simply "not mashed" could be all you need as long as it performed satisfactorilly beforehand.

Another way to view it is that the same part has a cost of $x, and a fancier unit has cost $y, but you have to pay $x so the cost to upgrade is $(y-x)

Do check the specs first though - if you can count the teeth on both the biggest and smallest cog, then look up the specs of the part you want to buy and make sure it suits. No point getting a fancy derailleur that won't handle your current cassette.

Also consider whether your chain was damaged in the crash, and whether a new one is appropriate. Might be better to do that than spend more on another mech, which could go the same way as the first one if you crash out again.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.