I need to replace my cassette and found out that there are two types that I can get for an 8-speed. I usually replaced the Shimano CS-HG41 by itself. However there is also the Shimano CS-HG31 8-speed Cassette. I would like to know what are the difference between them (HG31 and HG41) and which one is better.

Thanks for sharing your knowledge :)

1 Answer 1


HG31 has the sprockets painted black. I'm not sure, but the largest ones may also be on a riveted steel spider construction, eliminating the possibility of recycling any of the unworn sprockets.

HG41 is nickel plated and looks much shiner, and may be more resistant to corrosion. The sprockets are usually individual ones pinned together and can be seperated (once the pin heads are ground off) to make custom ratios or reuse unworn sprockets. Hardly anyone does this but I often keep unworn/low wear 32, 34 and 36t sprockets to make cassettes with lower gear ranges than normal, which can be useful for some people.

Lifespan and performance will be similar though the shiny nickel is easier to clean than the matt black

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.