4

Looking to build a daily on a steel frame, tempted to go for a higher end (Marin, Kona, some Raleigh) but I am wondering if the double or triple butted tubes are more fragile ?

For example if you put a child seat clamped on the seat tube (edited from seat post, I want to clamp on seat tube), it will be attached where the tube is thinner, is this more dangerous than a simple butted (gas pipe type) frame?

Another example is if you tow a trailer attached to the frame.

I've seen this is also a concern for some ebike users with torque arms, they are worried that where the torque arm rests (to avoid the hub to turn on the dropout) on the seat or chain stays is where the tubes are thinner (provided that the rear triangle is butted).

Am I overthinking or are basic, non butted frames better for those uses?

3
  • 1
    The seat post is independent of whether the frame is multiple butted or not
    – MaplePanda
    Commented Jun 25, 2023 at 17:40
  • 2
    There may be some jargon here - the seat post is removable, the seat tube is welded into the frame. Also, some kid seats clamp high on the seatpost and some clamp low on the seattube.
    – Criggie
    Commented Jun 25, 2023 at 18:56
  • Edited, I was thinking of seat tube
    – tweedi
    Commented Jun 25, 2023 at 20:34

1 Answer 1

4

Trailer won't be an issue. Most trailers attach to the rear axle, and the bike can withstand lots of load in that location. Remember that bike has to withstand pedaling loads on the chain, which are far greater than loads any trailer will put in there. The maximal load of a trailer will happen when braking hard. Let's say you brake at 0.5 g, and there is 70 kg on the trailer. That's 35 kg of load. On the other hand, a 90 kg person pulling up on rear pedal at 25 kg and pulling up from handlebars at 30 kg using a 50T chainring creates a chain load of 286 kg. If a bike can withstand a chain load of 286 kg, it can withstand a trailer braking load of 35 kg.

About seat post, that's not optimal for a child seat. The child seat will probably have lots of leverage, which can damage the seat post or maybe even the seat tube depending on how long the leverage is and how much weight there is for the child seat. Most seat posts are not made for that kind of leverage.

Far better is a child seat that attaches to the rack attachment points on a bike. For example Surly Nice Rack can carry 36 kg. Presumably the frames that this rack is intended for (Long Haul Trucker, Disc Trucker) can withstand the said 36 kg. So a touring bike frame should be able to carry a lightweight child.

Pick a touring bike frame. It will do anything you want, pull a trailer, carry a child, carry lots of cargo on the rear (and maybe front) racks.

As for e-bikes, a hub motor does not have the capability of detecting how hard you pedal, it's binary (pedaling or not). So the riding feel is very unnatural, in contrast to the natural feeling of mid-drives with proper torque sensors.

1
  • Thanks for this great answer, adds a useful perspective. If I have to go tourer for my workhorse I will, I was hoping to go for a more standard frame (MTB 90s) for a much, much cheaper build (and also less regrets if it's stolen in the city).
    – tweedi
    Commented Jun 25, 2023 at 20:39

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.